One of the great things about blogs is that it allows scientists to express their ideas in a more open and direct way. The old way to criticize a paper was to write a letter or a paper and try to get it published. Now, anyone can provide arguments and discuss a paper for the world to see.
In 2004 I tried to publish a rebuttal of the paper “Potential causes for amphibian declines in Puerto Rico” by Burrowes, Joglar and Green, published in Herpetologica. Unfortunately, the editors decided that the wording in their paper was vague enough that it made it hard for them to justify my comments as a rebuttal. I recently stumbled upon the original emails, so I decided to make my original comments of that paper available here. As a disclaimer, I worked with the first two authors for several years and I was one of the students that collected the data used in that paper during that time.
The full citation of the paper is:
Burrowes, Patricia A., Rafael L. Joglar, and David E. Green. 2004. Potential causes for amphibian declines in Puerto Rico. Herpetologica 60: 141-154.
Some of the problems of the paper are: read more »